Patentability Assessments: All You Need To Know 

In the fast-paced world of innovation, securing intellectual property rights is crucial for inventors and businesses alike. Patents, in particular, play a pivotal role in protecting novel and valuable inventions. However, not all inventions are eligible for patent protection. To determine whether your creation meets the necessary criteria, a patentability assessment is essential. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the intricacies of patentability assessments, the conditions for patentability, and the differences between a patent assessment and a patent search. 

What is a Patent Assessment? 

A patent assessment is a preliminary examination that reviews whether an invention may be patentable. This assessment can be conducted before initiating the patent application process. Its primary purpose is to identify any potential issues or obstacles related to patentability, allowing inventors and businesses to address them proactively. By conducting a patent assessment, you can save both time and money by avoiding the costly and time-consuming patent application process for inventions that may not meet the necessary criteria. 

What Are the Conditions for Patentability? 

To obtain a patent for your invention, you must fulfil several conditions, which are crucial for patent eligibility: 

• Usefulness: Your invention must serve a useful purpose or provide a practical benefit. 

• Novelty: It must be entirely new and not publicly disclosed before the filing date of your patent application. 

• Non-Obviousness: Your invention should not be an obvious improvement on an existing patented invention. It must demonstrate a level of inventiveness that goes beyond what someone skilled in the relevant field would consider obvious. 

• Sufficient Disclosure: Your patent application must contain enough information to enable a person with general knowledge in the industry to understand how your invention works. 

• Eligible Subject Matter: Inventions can include products, processes, methods, and workflows, provided they meet the specific requirements for patentability within their respective categories. 

What Does a Patentability Assessment Consist Of? 

A patentability assessment is a multifaceted process designed to evaluate the potential patentability of an invention thoroughly. Here are the key components of a patentability assessment: 

1. Novelty Search

A novelty search is a critical step in a patentability assessment. It involves determining the uniqueness of your invention compared to known technology. This search scans through existing patents, patent applications worldwide, and relevant literature to identify prior art that may affect the patentability of your invention. 

2. Detailed Analysis

A patentability assessment goes beyond a simple patent search. It includes a detailed analysis of the references found during the novelty search. This analysis aims to assess how your solution significantly differs from existing technology and whether it meets the conditions for patentability. 

3. Written Report on Patentability

Upon completion of the assessment, you will receive a comprehensive written report. This report outlines the findings of the novelty search and the patentability assessment. It provides valuable insights into the potential obstacles and opportunities related to patenting your invention. 

4. Identifying Obvious Combinations

In addition to novelty, a patentability assessment also considers whether combinations of prior art could make your invention obvious. This is a crucial aspect of evaluating non-obviousness, one of the key conditions for patentability. 

5. Consideration of Other Patentability Requirements

Besides novelty and non-obviousness, a patentability assessment also takes into account other patentability requirements such as utility and eligible subject matter. This holistic approach ensures that all aspects of patent eligibility are thoroughly examined. 

What’s the Difference Between a Patent Assessment and a Patent Search? 

Patent Search 

A patent search is a less comprehensive process that focusses solely on searching for prior patents using online databases. Its primary purpose is to identify prior art that may affect the patentability of your invention. Key points to consider about patent searches include: 

• Cost: Patent searches are generally less expensive than patentability assessments. 
• Reliability: While patent searches can identify potential obstacles, they do not provide the in-depth analysis offered by patentability assessments. 
• Variability in Cost: The cost of a patent search can vary based on the complexity of the search and the databases used. 
• Decision-Making: Patent searches help you consider your business goals and available resources when deciding whether to pursue a patent. 

Patentability Assessment 

A patentability assessment encompasses a patent search within it but goes beyond to offer a detailed analysis of the findings. Here are key points about patentability assessments: 

• Comprehensive Analysis: Patentability assessments provide a detailed and reliable evaluation of patentability. 
• Suitability for Newcomers: They are particularly suitable for newcomers to the patent system who may not have the expertise to analyse search results themselves. 
• Identifying Potential Barriers: Patentability assessments help identify potential barriers before significant patenting costs are incurred. 

• Valuable Insights: They provide valuable insights into patentability and potential objections. 
• Cost Variability: The cost of a patentability assessment can also vary based on the complexity of the search and the expertise of the professionals involved. 
• Limitations: It’s important to note that patentability assessments are limited to assessing patentability and do not address the practicality or commercial viability of the invention. In some cases, professional opinions may be needed to assess practicality. 

Should You Choose a Patent Search or a Patentability Assessment? 

The choice between a patent search and a patentability assessment depends on your specific circumstances and needs: 

Patent Search 

Choose a patent search if: 

• You are experienced and confident in analysing search results yourself. 
• You are willing to pursue a patent even if the invention is new and you are aware of potential obstacles. 

Patentability Assessment 

Opt for a patentability assessment if: 

• You are new to the patent system and require a detailed and reliable assessment of patentability. 
• You want to identify potential barriers before investing significant resources in the patenting process. 
• You are seeking funding and wish to strengthen your case for investment by demonstrating the patentability of your invention. 

Minesoft Makes Patent Search Simple 

Navigating the world of patents and conducting comprehensive searches can be a daunting task. Fortunately, Minesoft offers solutions that simplify the patent search process. Minesoft Origin is a powerful platform that assists users looking to patent their own processes or methods. With its user-friendly interface and easy-to-use features, Minesoft Origin streamlines the search for prior art and helps inventors and businesses make informed decisions regarding patentability.  

In conclusion, patentability assessments are a crucial step in the patenting process, helping inventors and businesses determine whether their creations meet the necessary criteria for patent protection. While patent searches provide valuable information, patentability assessments offer a more comprehensive and detailed analysis, making them ideal for newcomers to the patent system and those seeking a thorough evaluation of patentability. Minesoft’s suite of global patent intelligence solutions can further simplify the patent search process, making it easier for individuals and businesses to protect their innovative ideas. So, whether you’re a seasoned inventor or a newcomer to the world of patents, request a demo today and take the first step toward securing your intellectual property rights.